Skip to main content

ENG 112: College Composition II (AL): Identify Scholarly Information

Direct comments to aanderson@nvcc.edu

Overview

How To Identify Scholarly Information

Sources of information can range from being not scholarly, to very scholarly, to somewhere in the middle.  Each source will go somewhere on this Scale of Scholarliness:

          0                                                5                                             10          
|------------------------------------------|-----------------------------------------|

Least Scholarly                     Mid-Level                        Most Scholarly

 

.Where on the Scale of Scholarliness does your source fall?
To make your determination, consider the six things listed below.  Click on each box to learn more.

Author Credentials Audience purpose
Publisher Editing/Review References


All images are in the public domain or under Creative Commons licenses. 

Where Does Your Source Fit?

Author

No credentials                                                      Expert with
                                                                             credentials

     |------------------------------------|-----------------------------------|

 

.

Publisher

Self-published                                                     Scholarly press

    |-------------------------------------|-----------------------------------|

 

.

Vocabulary

Basic                                                                          Scholarly,
                                                                                  advanced

    |-------------------------------------|------------------------------------|

 

.

Editing/Review

None                                                                   Peer reviewed

    |-------------------------------------|------------------------------------|

 

.

References

None                                                                 List of Scholarly
                                                                                  Sources

    |-------------------------------------|------------------------------------|

 

.

What other factors would you consider?

___________________________________________________

What else would you want to know about this source?  

____________________________________________________

.

Based on where your source falls on the sliding scales above, what is your final judgment about your source for college research?

 

Least Scholarly                                              Most Scholarly

  |--------------------------------------|-------------------------------------|