Compare the information with what you've learned from other sources, including encyclopedias, books, periodical articles, or other websites.
Check to see if the website tells you what sources it used, such as books, periodical articles, other websites, or experts.
Any obvious sloppiness, such as spelling problems, typos, or dead links? If a website is sloppy in some areas, it may be sloppy in others -- such as accuracy.
What is the reputation of the author or organization?